Friday, 15 May 2009

On Writing

Ideas are the most powerfully creations of men. Ideas send men to the deepest oceans, the highest mountains and inspire infinite other feats. But ideas come from the mind. No one can look into another man’s mind. The only way for an idea to have any influence on anything apart from its creator is for this idea to be communicated to others. A man can tell and show another his ideas. But what exactly one says is usually forgotten, even by the speaker, in a blink of an eye. Speech is not a good way of communicating ideas over vast distances of continents and the even bigger distances of time. To make others know one’s ideas hundreds of centuries after one’s death and in yet undiscovered lands one must write them down.

Writing is an immense challenge. Ideas in a piece of writing may be referring to realities of the writer’s World which are totally alien to the reader. Competency of a writer thus must be judged on whether the reader understands what the writer is trying to say. The most general rule of writing thus must be to make the written text independent of any circumstances and conditions which are particular to the writer. In other words, written work has to be timeless.

This is not denying that some writing may have the purpose of only informing someone who is well aware of the situation and is in close proximity. An SMS text message to a friend saying “I’ll be late” does not require any explanation of why or how or anything else. But this particular area of writing is not concerned with communicating sophisticated ideas. The area of writing we are concerned with is the communication of complex thoughts which inevitably requires the quality of timelessness.

In my experience the method of making a piece of writing timeless can be broken down into 4 parts 3 of which are interrelated:

1) Contents – knowledge of the subject matter
2) Structure of the text
3) Language of the text
4) Peer review – get someone else to read it

The writer must fully know what he is writing about. He must be intimately familiar with all the exceptions, counter arguments and all other aspects of an idea down to the most trivial. If the writer doesn’t have this knowledge then the last three parts of good writing outlined above are useless. This is because the last three parts deal with sculpting knowledge into something other can understand with the use of writing. If the knowledge is not there in the first place, there is nothing to sculpt.

The second part of making a piece of writing good is structure. The writer must have a general plan of his work before he writes the first word. Just like a war leader does not launch an attack without clear understanding of his objectives and the ways of achieving them a writer does not start spewing out sentences in the hope that someone will understand him. A writer must have a plan of how he will lead the reader through to the conclusions the writer wants the reader to have. The actual plan will always be inseparably from the subject matter. No two plans will be identical and in some cases may be utterly different. But in general all good plans of texts will lead the reader to what the writer wants them to be lead to. One of my professors once used an analogy I thought illustrates this concept of structure perfectly. He said that one should make points of explanation in one’s essay seem like links in a strong and heavy chain instead of fragile glass beads on a thin string.

The writer is now ready to write. The writer must not lose track of the fact that he is trying to convey ideas. This means that the language he uses to express these ideas should not hinder the reader from understanding them. Rhetorical garnish can easily obscure the ideas which are being expressed and end up misleading the reader. To avoid this writer must stick to a minimalistic approach. The language used by the writer should be neutral. It should not have a meaning in itself. The meaning is in the content of the text and not in the language used. He must cut out everything that can be cut out. The writer must be on a constant hunt for smaller and simpler words and sentences. This may mean spending hours puzzling over each sentence and trying numerous combinations but it is well worth the effort. However, this zeal to cut may lead the writer to cutting out most of the meaning too. To combat this tendency the writer should keep the text concise but not at the expense of clarity, and keep the text clear but not at the expense of conciseness.

After these efforts the writer may feel that his text is as good as it can be. This may be true but he cannot be a fair judge to this. He must submit his text to review of others. The more people read the text the more mistakes may be pointed out that the writer, who is after all only human, may have missed. Another point is that the writer is ultimately writing for others to read so he needs to make sure that others understand his text.

At the end, only time can say whether a text is well written and achieves the aims of the writer but the guidelines outlined certainly will increase the chances of success of the writer.

Sunday, 3 May 2009

On the Virtues of Gay Marriage

We do not treat people equally because all are equal. We treat people equally because all are different. These differences make everyone so valuable. One cannot exactly know how a person thinks or what experiences he has had thus one will never predict what kind of contribution that person can make to society.

In order to allow a person the maximum scope within which he is able to exploit his knowledge, talents and ambitions, and thus contribute something, law treats everyone the same so everyone has a level playing field. Arbitrary rules which elevate some while dragging other down are avoided. Discrimination and privileges are frowned upon. However this does not mean in any way that one must automatically like other people. Not liking someone is subjective and arbitrary. It dictates how one treats others in private personal relationships but it should not prevent one from recognising a person’s contributions.

In modern society there are few areas of life where illiberal discrimination still exists. Slavery has been abolished, women have been set free and given the vote, and justice no longer recognises a colour of a man, at least not in Europe and not in theory in USA. Since enlightenment we have been free to think. But even though most battles have been won by liberalism the war is not over. Probably the last area where prejudice and lack of respect for freedom of men still exist is in sexual orientation. Gay marriage is an example of a much wider fight for freedom of people to love who they truly love and not be coerced to betray their real feelings. It is also a fight for those feelings to be tolerated and accepted as just as valid as feelings of other people. Many argue against gay marriage because they do not want this tolerance to be allowed. Liberty, as it turns out, has enemies of all political creeds. Lets examine of the main arguments against gay marriage and by extension against gay rights.

Marriage, in a strictly utilitarian sense, is the commitment of two people to a lasting relationship and a signal to the rest of the world, predominantly to the state, to treat the pair as a unit. This manifests itself mostly in taxation, housing rights and other administrative policies.

As it stands right now marriage mostly remains a privilege of the heterosexual. The majority discriminates against the minority of homosexuals in dictating that they are not allowed to be recognised as married. But this fails to recognise the possible contributions same sex couples can make to our society. This discrimination is also silly, entirely arbitrary and dangerous.

In order to avoid sounding religious and dogmatic some may argue along the utilitarian path and say that the original point of marriage was to provide more stable conditions in which to raise children. This pre-dates all religious thought by the virtue of happening at the dawn of humanity, before superstition and other cognitive side effects created the idea of God. The argument says that same sex couples are incapable of having children so there is no point in gay couples having marriages. It is true that same sex couples cannot reproduce. Same sex couples can however adopt (another topic of gay rights movement) and provide a loving and carrying home just as often as heterosexual couples, as proven by research. Does this not mean that providing same sex couples an opportunity to marry will result on average in even better home for their adopted children? Don’t gay marriages encourage same sex couples to adopt unwanted children and provide them with a loving home and thus benefiting society? It seems that from a utilitarian point of view same sex couples provide a net benefit, especially to orphans.

One must recognise that extending the definition of marriage to same sex couples does not in any way damage the marriage between heterosexual couples. How can it? homosexual couples are not going to climb through the window at night and steal heterosexual couples' marriage certificate. Does extending the definition of marriage result in heterosexual couples losing their love or affect their marriage? Obviously not. Imagine a situation in a heterosexual relationship where one partner, lets say the husband, tell his wife “honey, same sex marriage now is allowed, I don’t think I love you anymore. We have to split up.” Of course this is ridiculous. Discriminating against same sex couples on these grounds is not rational. It is a whim, a silly opinion, it is arbitrary.

Saying that we ought to have discrimination in one arbitrary area of life and have equality in all other areas of life may result in loss of all equality. If we can arbitrarily discriminate in one area of life, why not two areas? How about three? How about all of them? This is what arbitrariness is. The slippery slope to loss of equality before the law is thus established.

It seems to me that by following the liberal principle of equality before the law and thus extending definition of marriage to same sex couples will result in more equality before the law and a clear benefit to society. It will not result in anything catastrophic. How can recognising love and commitment between two people be a bad thing? One is perfectly entitled to dislike the gays, but why try to coerce them, or prevent them from doing good for the rest?

Saturday, 18 April 2009

Women and Men in the Army

The British Army tests the physical ability of its soldiers differently depending on soldier’s sex. This is both arbitrary and dangerous. It certainly goes against any feminist view that men and women ought to be treated equally.

The reason for this discrimination is the clear difference between physical ability and the capacity to improve this ability of an average man and average woman. It is thought that physical tests may be made fairer by setting the standard to be achieved by women lower than the standard to be achieved by men. This seemingly creates relatively the same difficulty level. This method tests for relatively the same level of effort from the test subjects at the expense of testing absolute physical ability. For example it is thought that if an average woman can run slower than an average man she has to put in more effort than the man to achieve the man’s ability to run. But if the required standard for the woman is lowered by the difference between average man and average woman, the female test subject will be tested for the same amount of effort. The woman no longer has to achieve same absolute level of fitness, but only a relative level of fitness.

This is entirely arbitrary. There are women who are taller than certain men. This gives a certain advantage to the taller women in relative tests. The taller women need to show less effort than the shorter man to pass the tests. But the tests look for a certain level of effort as explained earlier. This implies that one should take the height of test subjects into account and also discriminate by height. However this creates problems. All individuals are different in most aspects. To truly create a fair test that tests the effort of an individual one must create a different test specifically tailored for everyone. This is impossible. It is entirely impractical. The main reason however is that effort is not really quantifiable and thus subjective rather than objective. One cannot measure the absolute level of effort or the relative effort in relation to other test subjects. Thus it seems that to try to test effort will always remain arbitrary, a matter of an opinion not based on any fact. This is not fair to all involved because in the pursuit of trying to test everyone to the same standard of effort all end up being tested to different, somewhat random, standards. The only way to test objectively is to hold everyone to the same easily measurable standard and thus test everyone in the same test with the same requirements for passing the test. This of course will test the absolute level of fitness not the effort someone puts into their fitness training or the effort put in on the day of the tests. But this is better.

The nature of the job of a soldier stays the same irrespective of the sex. All rifles, grenades and ammunition weigh the same. When a female soldier picks up a rifle that rifle does not readjust its mass accordingly. The nature of war dictates that absolutes like the absolute ability to carry a weight or run or fight determines the winner or loser. By testing sexes differently the British Army denies this nature. Different pass criteria in physical tests seem to imply that the enemy will fight female soldiers differently from men. This is self evidently not true.

I do recognise that in certain situations a female soldier is required. An example of this may be to help another female rape victim, who clearly will be feeling particularly uncomfortable around male soldiers. Another example is that in certain cultures women were brought up not to interact with males and thus will be only willing to communicate with female soldiers. My argument does not concern these responsibilities however. I am only talking about pure combat troops.

To really be fair and not arbitrary the British Army should have equal test for everyone. This will also help to test for the absolute readiness of a soldier to fight. An enemy soldier will try his best to kill British soldiers all the same irrespective of sex of that British soldier. The army should not think in terms of women or men. It ought to think in terms of soldiers. If that soldier passes the single absolute physical test the soldier is fit for duty, if not than soldier is not fit for duty. Of course this will result is less women passing physical tests and thus having less women on the battlefield fighting. But this is irrelevant, whoever can do the fighting better should do the fighting. This may be a woman or a man if she or achieved certain levels of ability.

Thursday, 9 April 2009

Civil Unions instead of Gay Marriage

One may think that civil unions for the gays are marriage in all but name. The gays have equal rights. But if they have equal rights in all but name, why not name these rights that which they are, i.e. marriage?! The reason if course is that they do not enjoy equal rights.

They also do not enjoy equal consideration by the majority of people. The recent California ballot initiative, Proportion 8, to define marriage as between man and woman and to limit marriage to such an arrangement has shown this. The initiative was passed by the majority. The majority of people do not like gays (mostly derived from the bible and other religious intolerances and nonsense not from some fact). This fight the gays are fighting is not about marriage, it is about much wider want of being accepting as equals. If gays were equal to other people in the eyes of the public there would be no arguments about them being able to have equal rights, like a right to marry.

One can only treat everyone equally by applying the same standards and rules to everyone. When one singles out a group or individuals and applies different rules and standards one is discriminating, one is not treating that group equally. Some would argue that it is possible to treat the gays equally yet somehow keep them separate. They propose to keep marriage for normal heterosexuals and civil unions for the gays but to have the civil unions grant the gays the same rights as marriage grants to heterosexuals. This would be exactly the same as the racist Jim Crow laws that kept the blacks separate but equal. Since the gays have done nothing wrong except to be born the way they are, singling them out and preventing them from doing something is treating them not equally. Preventing someone from causing damage or injury is justifiable. But what are the gays being prevented from doing exactly? They are prevented from expressing love and commitment to that love and to have this recognised by society. It seems strange to deny people to do this.

Second Amendment and Liberal Democracy

The 2nd amendment of U.S. constitution seems to allow Americans gun ownership. Some argue that 2nd amendment is necessary because it is a safeguard against government tyranny. This argument strikes me as false.

It seems to me that a government that cannot steer itself towards liberty through the use of checks and balances but instead has to be coerced by its gun-touting-populous away from tyrannical rule is not worth having. The argument for gun access to safeguard liberal democracy is an argument against liberal democracy.

Liberal democracy’s nature is self-sustaining, through peaceful measures and voluntary agreement of all. Faults of government are exposed by the free press, by other branches of government and punished by an independent judiciary where appropriate. The system has accountability and oversight. To say that liberal democracy can only be sustained by an armed and angry mob is to deny this nature of liberal democracy. But this nature is undeniable. Liberal democratic process is flourishing in many places around the World where gun ownership is curtailed or even banned. Example of UK comes to mind.

The argument for ownership of guns to protect liberal democracy thus flows from faulty premises, namely that liberal democracy is sustainable only through gun-touting-mob. A separation of arguments for gun ownership and maintenance of liberal democracy is called for.

Monday, 23 February 2009

Kremlin's power

All power in Russia is concentrated in Kremlin. Duma (the parliament) acts like a rubber stamp because it is controlled by the Kremlin’s party. The regional governors are appointed by Kremlin. There exists a thin but very powerful and rich layer of military, intelligence and mafia types which is well connected with the Kremlin. This is the layer controls most business and has involvement with almost all national activities. However this layer in no way opposes the Kremlin but is fully subservient. Corruption allows this layer some independence in its activities.

This form of government can be seen as nonhereditary monarchy with all nepotism and cronyism which monarchy implies. Ironically this is exactly what Perestroika wanted to get rid of and the communist revolution before that. It seems that no matter what the common Russian people do, they end up with the same government but under a different political banner. From the Czar to the General Secretary of the Party to the President, all men who rule Russia have ruled it using the same methods. Namely using absolute or near absolute authority to suppress any opposition to achieving goals, which of course are chosen by them alone.

This happens because there are no checks and balances on power in Russia. In other countries long histories of institutional development produced very robust mechanisms to spread power around and to add accountability to every institution. When someone gets into power they are not really in power. They are simply in charge of one of the institutions. Rules and good ethic is enforced by other institutions. There is no free reign. In Russia the opposite is true. Whoever has the power has freedom to do whatever he pleases.

This is somewhat of a medieval way of governing. In the long term it is nowhere as productive or kind to its citizens as a system with more accountability.

This reason for this state of affairs seems to be that Enlightenment never took root in Russia. In other countries ideas of Enlightenment grew into liberalism and democracy. This was accomplished by gradual change rather than revolution. It is impossible to come to conclusive understanding why Enlightenment never took root. But what is true is that Russia needs to start to develop these institutions as soon as possible for its own sake and for the sake of the World. Unfortunately there is no reason why this should happen now or in anytime in the future.

Friday, 20 February 2009

Death Penalty

Death penalty rests on three arguments:

1) Retributive justice or eye for an eye
2) It is cheaper to execute someone than keep him alive indefinitely
3) It is a deterrent for criminals

The first point is subjective and the last two can be objective. The first point relies on jurisprudence and philosophy. As such there is no clearly correct position. Every side has got rational arguments for their position. The supporters argue that the punishment ought to fit the crime, for murder this means death. Others say that two wrongs do not make a right, or that an eye for an eye will make the whole world blind. It may be argued that matters of personal preference should not enter rational analysis. As David Hume said the question of what ought to happen cannot be derived from what is factual (Hume's guillotine). Thus the arguments of personal preference of what ought to be a proper ethical position on the death penalty are all in doubt since they cannot be backed up by facts.

It is true that is much cheaper to kill someone and be done with it rather than having to pay for food and accommodation for indefinite amount of time. However our system of justice relies having extremely strong argument for someone’s guilt in order to avoid punishing the innocent. Standards for proving someone to be guilty and fit for capital punishment are very high and actually impose a cost far higher than of keeping someone locked up for life. On a cost-benefit analysis one may not argue that the death penalty is the cheaper argument. One may argue this only when the system of justice is not so fussy about proving someone innocent, but is far less desirable for our society.

It seems to be logical to think that the death penalty is a deterrent for murder. But then people rarely commit murder thinking they will get caught. Most simply fail to account for the risk of the death penalty. Since each murder case is unique with many unique causes, it is statistically hard to analyse the effect of the death penalty on the murder rate. Some econometric analysis shows a negative correlation between murder rate and the use of the death penalty others show the opposite. Same say that whenever death penalty has been suspended the murder rate stayed about the same but others would argue that other circumstantial socio-economic factors played a part in keeping the murder rate down.

All arguments for the death penalty are dubious. Unfortunately most counterarguments are somewhat dubious too. The question returns to jurisprudence and choosing the lesser of two evils on subjective grounds. I think the strongest argument remains that innocent people have been killed in the name of justice. Clearly the system has been shown to be fallible. Thus to avoid killing the innocent death penalty ought not be used at all. Lifelong imprisonment allows new evidence to come forward and a chance to redeem oneself. This is why the civilised countries do not have the death penalty.